One Saturday in June 2002,
Eugene Pallisco and his new bride, Lesley Keith, celebrated their
$35,000 wedding and reception at the Ritz-Carlton in Dearborn.
The
bride sported her 2-carat diamond ring. One hundred guests dined on
crab cakes rémoulade, wild mushroom tartlets and $40 bottles of French
merlot. They danced.
Not in attendance: Pallisco’s other wife and their four children.
Seven years later, Keith, 37, who now lives in Arizona, is seeking an
annulment and money from Pallisco, 44, of West Bloomfield. She is
charging that he is a bigamist who kept his 15-year marriage with his
other wife a secret from her.
Pallisco, who is in the scrap metal and real estate business, admits
that he was married to Marie Ann Hallman, who was born in August 1970
and is of West Bloomfield, at the time of his wedding to Keith. But he
said the latter union was never official because the marriage license
was never filed with the county after the ceremony.
Oakland County Circuit Judge Cheryl Matthews has set a Sept. 1 trial date in the case.
Pallisco
tried to get the court file sealed earlier this month, saying the
allegations were "scandalous" and would ruin his reputation. The file
includes the then-happy couple's wedding pictures taken at the
Ritz-Carlton in Dearborn, where the wedding was celebrated.
Matthews denied his motion, saying dryly, "The rice is still on the wedding photos."
He says, she says
Pallisco is a well-to-do
businessman who was living a double life, said Keith's attorney, Norman
Lippitt. "He told her from the beginning he was divorced," Lippitt
said. "She had no reason to doubt him. This was a bigamist's marriage."
Pallisco
has several explanations, according to the court files. In addition to
his contention that "it's not legal because the marriage license was
not filed," he also argues in a separate lawsuit in Oakland County that
an "unknown woman" -- Keith, the woman he exchanged vows with in the
photos -- applied for a marriage license without his knowledge in 2002
and is "impugning him regarding his marital status."
In that suit, Judge Rae Lee Chabot, unaware of the Ritz-Carlton wedding, ruled the marriage application invalid.
Another
explanation offered by Pallisco's attorney, Robert Sheehan, is that
Pallisco is the victim of a bizarre extortion that began in 2000 when a
Detroit police officer tried to "shake down" Pallisco's scrap and
recycling business. Sheehan said Pallisco knew Keith casually, and when
she learned of his problems with the police, told him she and her
family had connections with the Police Department. If they had a
"pretend" marriage, Sheehan said, then Pallisco, too, would be "family"
and the shakedowns would end.
"The wedding was a sham, and she knew it," Sheehan said. "And despite my client's better judgment, he agreed to it."
What about the diamond ring and the $35,000 wedding?
Problems from the Start
"Yes," Sheehan said. "There was an event. And a ring. I'm sure you've seen the pictures."
However it ends, the marriage was far from a match made in heaven, according to court documents.
Pallisco
met Keith in June 1997 at Picano's restaurant in Troy, where she worked
as a bartender and waitress. In February of the following year, Keith
said Pallisco told her he was divorced and asked her out for dinner,
according to court filings.
In
the course of their courtship, she said, he never took her to his home
-- something she found odd. But by 1998, he was supporting her, she
said in her court filings. Pallisco, according to the suit, took her
and her family members on trips to Las Vegas and Chicago, and showered
her with gifts.
Four
days before the 2002 wedding, Keith applied for a marriage license at
the Oakland County Clerk's Office, listing Pallisco as the groom. The
night before the wedding, Keith said in her suit, Pallisco wanted to
cancel it, but he went ahead with it. They fought and argued on their
wedding night, the suit said, and Pallisco left.
Within
days of the wedding, the couple moved to Las Vegas and eventually to
Arizona, but Pallisco was gone for weeks at a time, missing holidays
and telling Keith he had out-of-state business, she said in her
complaint. Keith alleged she repeatedly asked him for a copy of the
marriage license so that she could open bank accounts in their names,
but he never produced one.
Pallisco's
attorney denied those allegations and said the two never lived
together. And any money Keith got was a loan from Pallisco, Sheehan
said. Pallisco has filed a suit in Arizona, asking for the money back.
Keith
eventually called the Oakland County Clerk's Office and learned that
the marriage license had never been filed by the minister who oversaw
the ceremony. In a sworn affidavit to the court, the minister, Robert
Zaloga, said he does not know why he failed to file the license, but
that he specifically recalls marrying the couple, who wanted the
ceremony to have a "Catholic tone."
"I
specifically recall having a casual conversation with Eugene and the
best man before the ceremony, including the fact that he was moving to
Las Vegas," Zaloga said.
By L.L. Brasier of the Detriot Free Press
Recent Comments