Call it a mother's intuition. Carrollton, TX resident Barbara Casey said she had an uneasy feeling from
the start about the man her daughter met at a local gym this summer and
began dating.
Bryon D. Drennan, 36, was almost too
polite, too controlled, said Mrs. Casey. And he quickly seemed to
become obsessed with her daughter, Stefanie Nicole Casey, a 28-year-old
former schoolteacher.
"Something didn't feel right about the way he presented himself," Mrs.
Casey said of her daughter's suitor. "I never really saw violence, but
there were things that gave me concern shortly after she began seeing
him."
Two days after Thanksgiving, Stefanie's body was
found under a pile of rocks on the shores of Lake Ontario in upstate
New York, near where the couple were married Nov. 3.
A
grand jury there last week indicted Mr. Drennan on second-degree murder
charges. Wayne County, N.Y., District Attorney Richard Healy said he
believes that Mr. Drennan, who is being held in the Wayne County jail
without bail, killed his bride because she wanted to leave him and
return to Texas.
"They'd only been married a month, but he was abusive," Mr. Healy said. "She was leaving him to go home."
Mr. Drennan's legal woes aren't contained to New York. Before his
arrest, Carrollton police began a separate investigation into a bigamy
complaint against him filed by his first wife, Rhonda, whom he'd
married in 1994.
Last month, Rhonda Drennan told police that she and her husband split
up over the summer, and that he remarried before their divorce was
finalized. Denton County records show that the couple's divorce
petition was filed on Aug. 26, but the final hearing isn't scheduled
until Feb. 23, 2009. Reached by phone, Ms. Drennan declined to be interviewed.
"We felt we had enough evidence to prove bigamy to send it to the
[Denton County] prosecutor's office," Carrollton police Officer Dustin
Bartram said. The case is now in the hands of prosecutors who will
determine how to proceed.
Bigamy – a third-degree felony
that carries a maximum penalty of 10 years in prison and $10,000 fine –
is a very rare charge. Officer Bartram said Carrollton has had only
five bigamy cases filed since 1993.
"The marriage they
had is not legal," said Mrs. Casey of Stefanie's union with Mr.
Drennan. She recalled Mr. Drennan telling her daughter that he was
divorced when the two met this summer. Soon the couple began living
together, and Mrs. Casey and her husband, Robert, saw little of their
daughter. "He isolated her from the family," Mrs. Casey said.
Move to New York
The couple moved to New York around the beginning of November and got
married in the town of Williamson. Mr. Drennan had lost his job with an
accounting firm and thought he'd have better prospects in upstate New
York, where his family still lived, Mrs. Casey said.
Far from her family and Texas roots, Stefanie seemed to realize that she'd made a mistake, said her mother. On one of her rare phone calls home, she told her mother that she was
being abused and said Mr. Drennan had been arrested for domestic
violence while they were on their honeymoon in Honolulu.
Police in Honolulu confirmed that Mr. Drennan was arrested Nov. 5 for
"abuse of a household member" and was ordered to stay away from the
victim for 24 hours. Stefanie called police from a Waikiki hotel and
reported that Mr. Drennan had injured both of her arms.
Two weeks after the honeymoon, Mrs. Casey said, Stefanie was ready to leave Mr. Drennan. "We'd made arrangements for her to come back home the day before
Thanksgiving, but he convinced her to come back," Mrs. Casey said.
Mr. Drennan telephoned to tell the Caseys that Stefanie would not be coming back to Texas after all. "He wouldn't let her call," Mrs. Casey said. "But she got on the phone and told us she loved us." That was the last time the Caseys spoke to their daughter.
On Thanksgiving Day, Mr. Drennan's mother called Williamson police to
report that he and his new wife were missing, New York State Police
Capt. Philip Pettine said. Later that day, Mr. Drennan returned to his
family's home, saying he had put Stefanie on a plane back to Texas.
The next day, police received a call from a woman who reported seeing a
man carry a plastic bag into the woods on Thanksgiving Day. She told
police that her son located the bag and found bloody clothing inside.
Capt. Pettine said the bag also contained other evidence: a
prescription bottle with Bryon Drennan's name on it, and a wooden
heart. When Mr. Drennan was questioned later that day, he admitted that
he had struck his wife in the head with a 10-pound weight from a
barbell set and stabbed her with the wooden heart, authorities said.
But Mr. Drennan said that he acted in self-defense and that Stefanie
was alive when he last saw her, Capt. Pettine said. Two days after
Thanksgiving, police – acting on another tip – found Stefanie's body
along the Lake Ontario shoreline.
Last week, the Casey family held a memorial service for their only daughter. "We want Stefanie to be remembered for the special person she was, and
not for this crime," Mrs. Casey said. "She was a victim, and I hope
that her story might save the life of someone else in this situation."
By Wendy Hundley of The Dallas Morning News
•March 11, 1994 – Bryon David Drennan and Rhonda Liberte are married in Henrietta, N.Y. They move to Texas the same year.
•Aug. 26, 2008 – Rhonda
Drennan of Carrollton files for divorce in Denton County. The divorce
is scheduled to be finalized Feb. 23, 2009.
•Nov. 3 – Mr. Drennan and Stefanie Nicole Casey, formerly of Carrollton, are married in Williamson, N.Y.
•Nov. 12 – Ms. Drennan files a bigamy complaint against Mr. Drennan with the Carrollton Police Department.
•Nov. 27 (Thanksgiving) – Ms. Casey is reported missing
•Nov. 29 – Ms. Casey's body is found under rocks near Lake Ontario. Mr. Drennan is arrested.
SOURCE: Dallas Morning News research
Recent Comments